Thursday, November 8, 2012

2012 Election: Obama's Coattails in California Congressional Races

President Obama had long “coattails” in California in the 2012 presidential election.  If current trends in the state’s 53 congressional races hold, California will send 38 Democrats and 15 Republicans to the U.S. House of Representatives when the 113th Congress convenes next January.  This will be a net gain of four seats for the Democrats in the California House delegation.

Nearly 72 percent of California U.S. House members will be Democrats in the 113th Congress – the highest percentage in more than 70 years.  The most recent Congress that had a higher percentage of Democrats in the California delegation was the 75th Congress (1937-39).  Back then California had just twenty House members, composed of fifteen Democrats, one Progressive and four Republicans.  Democrats comprised 75 percent of that delegation (80 percent if the Progressive is included as he caucused with the Democrats).  Those congressmen were elected with the Franklin Roosevelt/New Deal re-election landslide of 1936, when F.D.R. won all 58 California counties.

Since the Civil War (1861-65), just three Congresses have had higher shares of Democrats in the California House delegation than in the upcoming 113th Congress: (1) 44th Congress (1875-77), 75% Democratic; (2) 48th Congress (1883-85), 100% Democratic; (3) 75th Congress (1937-39), 75 or 80% Democratic.


The Democrats’ net gain of four House seats in California is a big change from 2008 when none of the Golden State’s 53 congressional districts turned over from one political party to another.  Except in 1940 and 2008, at least one California Democrat has won a Republican-held House seat in every presidential election won by a Democrat since 1892.  Click here for CalPolitiCal’s analysis of the 2008 congressional elections in California.

California House districts in the 2000’s were pro-incumbent party gerrymanders, purposely designed to entrench each party’s members.  The only House seat to switch parties in the entire decade was the old 11th Congressional District, where Democrat Jerry McNerney (D-Pleasanton) defeated seven-term Rep. Richard Pombo (R-Tracy).  That was a Republican-leaning district; it narrowly re-elected Rep. McNerney in 2010 despite backing Republicans Meg Whitman for governor and Carly Fiorina for U.S. Senate.  The competitive districts in 2012 exist because California voters created the Citizens Redistricting Commission via Proposition 11 in 2008 and Proposition 20 in 2010.  (The California Democratic Party and the California Republican Party strongly opposed Propositions 11 and 20.)

The 38 Democrats of the California House delegation will set another record next January.  They will comprise the largest partisan delegation of any state in any Congress in American history.  This breaks the record set by the Pennsylvania House delegation in the 69th Congress (1925-27), composed of 36 Republicans elected by Keystone State voters in the Calvin Coolidge landslide of 1924.  [Pennsylvania again had 36 Republican House members during a portion of the 71st Congress (1929-31), from June 4, 1929 until March 4, 1931.]

It is impossible for any other state to break California’s record at the present time.  The 36 House members elected by Texas comprise the second-largest House delegation.  Even if all Texas congressional districts elected a Republican (or, perhaps impossibly, a Democrat), the 36 Democrats or Republicans would still fall two short of California’s record.  Just two U.S. states have had more than 36 members in their House delegations – California from 1963 to present and New York from 1903 to 1983.

The largest partisan delegation that New York elected to the U.S. House was the 33 Republicans elected to the 67th Congress (1921-23) (followed by 32 Jacksonians in 1832 and 32 Whigs elected in 1848), according to Professor Kenneth Martis' Historical Atlas of United States Congressional Districts.  Although the Empire State had up to 45 House members, neither the Republicans nor Democrats dominated the congressional delegation because of Democratic strength in New York City and Republican voting proclivities Upstate.  The California House Democrats matched New York's record in 2002, when the Golden State elected 33 House Democrats.   Now, in 2012, Pennsylvania's record has fallen.

Assuming that Democrats win 200 seats in the House and 38 Democrats are elected from California in 2012, then the California Democrats will comprise nearly one in every five House Democrats (19 percent).  Assuming that Republicans win 235 House seats, then the fifteen House Republicans will comprise a mere six percent of the entire House Republican Conference.

The last time that California House Republicans were fewer than fifteen was in the 95th Congress (1977-79).  There were a mere fourteen Republicans in the 43-member California House delegation.  

When the 113th Congress convenes in January 2013, the Texas (24 out of 36) and Florida (17 out of 27) delegations will contain more House Republicans than California (15 out of 53).  Other states with 10 or more House Republicans will include Pennsylvania (13 out of 18) and Ohio (12 out of 16).  Those four states (Texas, Florida, Pennsylvania and Ohio) elected a total of 66 Republicans and 31 Democrats in November 2012.

From 2007 to 2013, the California House delegation consisted of 34 Democrats and 19 Republicans.  Redistricting following the 2010 Census of Population has shifted congressional district boundaries, beginning with the 2012 congressional election.  If current election returns hold, five seats in California effectively will have changed from one party to another; a Republican will have won a Democratic seat and five Democrats will have won Republican seats. 

The "turnovers" (seats shifting from one party to another) are as follows:

DEMOCRATIC HOUSE SEAT TURNING OVER TO A REPUBLICAN:
21st Congressional District:  Assemblyman David Valadao (R) has won a San Joaquin Valley seat now held more-or-less by Congressman Jim Costa (D).  Costa ran for re-election in a district that includes territory held by retiring Rep. Dennis Cardoza (D-Atwater, Merced County).  Rep.-elect Valadao (R) effectively is taking the seat of Rep. Cardoza (D).  (Voter registration as of Oct. 22nd: 47% Dem., 33% Rep., 16% Decline-to-State.)

FIVE REPUBLICAN HOUSE SEATS TURNING OVER TO DEMOCRATS:
7th Congressional District:  Democrat Ami Bera is leading in the suburban Sacramento County House seat, defeating longtime Republican Rep. Dan Lungren. (Voter registration as of Oct. 22nd: 39% Dem., 38% Rep., 19% Decline-to-State.)

26th Congressional District: Democrat Julia Brownley has won the Ventura County-based House seat that has been occupied by Simi Valley Republican Elton Gallegly since 1987.  Ms. Brownley defeated Republican state Sen. Tony Strickland, a protege of conservative Rep. Tom McClintock.  She is the first Democrat to represent the bulk of Ventura County since Rep. George Outland (D-Santa Barbara) held the Central Coast congressional seat from 1943-47.  (Voter registration as of Oct. 22nd: 40% Dem., 35% Rep., 20% Decline-to-State.)

Ventura is a quintessential presidential bellwether county, siding with the national electoral vote winner in 23 of the past 24 elections. The exception was 1976, when Ventura County favored President Gerald Ford over Gov. Jimmy Carter.

All 808 miles of U.S. 101 highway in California, from the Oregon border to downtown Los Angeles, will represented by a Democratic member of Congress next January, as a consequence of Ms. Brownley's victory.  (U.S. 101 now traverses fourteen congressional districts.)  The last time that the entire California coast from Oregon to Los Angeles elected Democrats to Congress was 130 years ago in 1882/3 when U.S. 101 was a dirt road called "El Camino Real" and automobiles did not exist.

In contrast, forty years ago, a drive the length of U.S. 101 in California was overwhelmingly in Republican congressional districts.  In 1972, a drive up U.S. 101 from its southern terminus near downtown Los Angeles to Oregon crossed Democratic congressional districts just within the city of Los Angeles, in the Morgan Hill, San Jose and Santa Clara section of Santa Clara County and in eastern San Francisco.  All of Ventura, Santa Barbara, San Luis Obispo, Monterey, San Benito, San Mateo, Marin, Sonoma, Mendocino, Humboldt and Del Norte counties were represented by Republican House members.  Once a motorist on U.S. 101 left the Hollywood hills [26th District, seat held by Rep. Tom Rees (D-Los Angeles)], the next Democratic congressional district was crossed nearly 350 miles north in Morgan Hill [9th District, seat held by Rep. Don Edwards (D-San Jose)], a few miles south of San Jose.  Another 350 miles on U.S. 101, from central San Francisco, across the Golden Gate Bridge, through the "Redwood Empire," to the Oregon border also was through Republican congressional districts in 1972.

36th Congressional District: Democrat Raul Ruiz is leading over Republican Rep. Mary Bono Mack in the eastern Riverside County House seat.  Mrs. Bono Mack is most famous as the widow of singer/Rep. Sonny Bono.  She won her late husband’s House seat in 1998 after Mr. Bono died in a skiing accident. (Voter registration as of Oct. 22nd: 39% Dem., 39% Rep., 17% Decline-to-State.)

The last House Democrat who represented eastern Riverside County (Palm Springs out to Indio and Blythe) was Rep. John V. Tunney (D-Riverside), who represented the entire county from 1965 until his election to the U.S. Senate in 1970.  Rep. Alfred McCandless (R-Bermuda Dunes) held the Riverside County-centered congressional district from 1983 to 1995.  In 1992, Rep. McCandless ran in the new eastern Riverside County district.  Reps. Sonny Bono and Mary Bono Mack followed him.  It was once very conservative territory; President Ronald Reagan won 65.1% of the vote in 1984 in Rep. McCandless's district.

41st Congressional District:  Democrat Mark Takano defeated Republican John Tavaglione in a new Riverside County House seat, centered on the cities of Riverside and Moreno Valley.  This is Mr. Takano’s third attempt to run for Congress in this area; apparently the “third time is a charm” for him.  (Voter registration as of Oct. 22nd: 42% Dem., 37% Rep., 16% Decline-to-State.)

When a new House seat was carved out of western Riverside County in 1992, Mr. Takano came close to winning.  The winner of that contest was Republican Ken Calvert.  Takano challenged Rep. Calvert in 1994, but lost by a wide margin in the national Republican/Gov. Pete Wilson landslide.  In 2008, Democrat Bill Hedrick came surprisingly close to defeating Rep. Calvert, an outcome that virtually no national political observer foresaw. 

Growth in the Inland Empire has resulted in creation of the new 41st District; Rep. Calvert won re-election in 2012 in the 42nd District.  The new House seat in Riverside County is more-or-less the functional replacement (via the game of “redistricting musical chairs”) of the Los Angeles/San Bernardino County House seat now occupied by retiring Republican Rep. David Dreier (R-San Dimas).

The last House Democrat who represented the city of Riverside was Rep. George Brown (D-San Bernardino County), whose district included a small portion of Riverside County from 1973 to 1993.

52nd Congressional District:   Democrat Scott Peters narrowly won the San Diego County district where Rep. Brian Bilbray (R) stood for re-election.  This district covers northern San Diego, Poway, much of coastal San Diego, the bulk of the San Diego central business district and Coronado. (Voter registration as of Oct. 22nd: 33% Dem., 34% Rep., 28% Decline-to-State.)

Rep. Bilbray previously represented a different San Diego County district from 1995 to 2001; now-Rep. Susan Davis (D-San Diego) defeated Bilbray in that district in 2000.  This was Republican Rep. "Duke" Cunningham's district, more-or-less, until his resignation from Congress in 2005 after he pled guilty to numerous federal criminal charges.  Mr. Bilbray won Cunningham's vacant seat; Democrat Francine Busby attempted to oust him in 2006 and 2010.

The five Republican-to-Democrat turnovers are offset by the single Republican-to-Democrat turnover, resulting in a net gain of four Democratic House seats in California in 2012.

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Obama vs. Romney - How California's Slates of Presidential Electors Are Selected

(For the list of 55 Obama/Biden electors from California, see below.)

California has 55 electoral votes in the 2012 presidential election "electoral college."  Under California law, whichever presidential candidate wins the statewide popular vote is awarded all 55 votes.  The electors assemble in mid-December in Sacramento to formally cast California’s votes for president and president. 

In recent presidential elections, the individual Democratic presidential/vice-presidential electors have been selected by the Democratic party nominee in each congressional district and by the party’s most recent U.S. Senate nominees for each Senate seat.  However, the adoption of Proposition 14 in June 2010 (“top two” primary system) has caused a change in this system.  Beginning with the 2012 presidential election, according to California Elections Code sec. 7100, “the candidate in each congressional district who received the largest number of votes in the primary election among the candidates who disclosed a preference for the Democratic Party shall designate one presidential elector …”

The new system for selecting Democratic presidential electors in California has at least two major implications.  First, in congressional districts where two Democrats will appear on the November ballot, the top vote-getter in the June election selects the Obama-Biden presidential elector for that district.  Therefore, “Pete” Stark, Brad Sherman and Joe Baca will select the Democratic electors in the 15th, 30th and 35th districts respectively, even if their Democratic opponents Eric Swalwell, Howard Berman and Gloria Negrete McLeod end up winning in November. 

Second, in congressional districts where no Democratic candidate advances to the November election, the losing Democrat with the most votes in June gets to name a presidential elector.  Democrats Jackie Conaway in the 8th District and Pete Aguilar in the 31st District will not appear on the November ballot, but each has the authority to name a Democratic presidential elector for California.

In other congressional districts, even where “sacrificial lamb” Democratic candidates are unlikely to defeat Republican opponents in November, the Democrat has the authority to name a presidential elector. This must be a valuable “consolation prize” for those Democrats who are unlikely to win.

The Republicans have a different system for selecting presidential/vice-presidential electors in California.  Proposition 14 did not directly affect it.  According to Elections Code section 7300, “the Republican nominees for Governor, Lieutenant Governor, Treasurer, Controller, Attorney General, and Secretary of State, the Republican nominees for United States Senator at the last two United States senatorial elections, the Assembly Republican leader, the Senate Republican leader, all elected officers of the Republican State Central Committee, the National Committeeman and National Committeewoman, the President of the Republican County Central Committee Chairmen's Association, and the chairperson or president of each Republican volunteer organization officially recognized by the Republican State Central Committee shall act as presidential electors …”

This means that if “Mitt” Romney wins the California popular vote, then Meg Whitman, Abel Maldonado, Mimi Walters, Tony Strickland, Steve Cooley, Damon Dunn and Carly Fiorina, all of whom have lost bids for statewide office, would meet in Sacramento in mid-December as members of the Electoral College.

The names and residence and business addresses of each presidential elector on each slate must be filed with California Secretary of State Debra Bowen by October 1, 2012.

UPDATE: NAMES OF CALIFORNIA'S 55 ELECTORS PLEDGED TO OBAMA/BIDEN
The following are the names of California's 55 Democratic electors.  At least eight of the 55 are relatives by blood or marriage of the congressional candidates who appointed them.  At least nine electors are non-residents of the congressional districts that they represent. (There is a cluster of non-resident electors in the San Joaquin Valley, where four of the six congressional districts will have electors who reside outside of the Valley.)  Some are financial contributors to the congressional candidates who appointed them.  Some are political consultants to their appointing powers.

California's 55 presidential electors will assemble in Sacramento on Monday, December 17th at 2:00 p.m. to cast the state's electoral votes for Barack Obama for President and Joe Biden for Vice President:

Dolores Clara Huerta - USS (Senator Boxer)
Bakersfield, CA

(Ms. Huerta is a prominent/legendary civil rights/labor leader)
 

Barbara Schraeger - USS (Senator Feinstein)
Sausalito, CA 

(Ms. Schraeger is a retired business consultant who is a campaign contributor to Sen. Dianne Feinstein)

Brooke Reed - CD 1
Fall River Mills, CA

(Democratic candidate Jim Reed appointed his daughter)
 

Daniel Leroux - CD 2
San Rafael, CA

(Democratic candidate Jared Huffman appointed a San Rafael attorney)
 

Patricia W. Garamendi - CD 3
Walnut Grove, CA

(Rep. John Garamendi appointed his wife)
 

Michael Williams Adams - CD 4
Roseville, CA
 

Kyriakos Tsakopoulos - CD 5
Carmichael, CA

(Rep. Mike Thompson appointed a non-resident of his district)
 

Sandy L. Nixon - CD 6
Sacramento, CA
 

Janine Vivienne Bera - CD 7
Elk Grove, CA

(Democratic candidate Dr. Ami Bera appointed his wife)
 

Aaron Samuel Conaway - CD 8
Phelan, CA

(Democratic candidate Jackie Conaway apparently appointed her son)

Ernest Joseph Vasti - CD 9
Stockton, CA

(Rep. Jerry McNerney appointed a local physician)

Ruben Antonio Villalobos - CD 10
Modesto, CA

(Democratic candidate Jose Hernandez appointed a Modesto criminal defense attorney)
 

Gwen Regalia - CD 11
Walnut Creek, CA

(Rep. George Miller appointed a former Walnut Creek city council member/mayor)
 

Jane Morrison - CD 12
San Francisco, CA

(Rep. Nancy Pelosi appointed a longtime San Francisco Democratic Party member, age 92+)
 

Geoffrey Pete - CD 13
Oakland, CA

(Rep. Barbara Lee appointed a local nightclub owner)
 

Ranada Stephenson - CD 14
Hillsborough, CA

(Rep. Jackie Speier appointed a local political activist/campaign donor)
 

Meriam Reynosa Louise - CD 15
San Leandro, CA

(Ms. Reynosa Louise, a nonresident of the district, is President of Southern Alameda County Young Democrats.  She is staff member for state Sen. Ellen Corbett.  As the highest Democratic vote winner in the congressional district in the June 2012 election, Rep. "Pete" Stark appointed her.)

Terry Reardon - CD 16
Sacramento, CA
(Rep. Jim Costa appointed Mr. Reardon, a former member of his state Assembly staff in Sacramento in the 1980s and a nonresident of his congressional district.  Mr. Reardon, who lists his employer as "retired," is a financial contributor to Rep. Costa's campaigns.  In the 1990s,, Mr. Reardon formed an organization called "Californians for Rail Transit.")


Susan Johnson - CD 17
Fremont, CA

(Rep. Mike Honda appointed Ms. Johnson.  She likely is the "Susan M. Johnson" of Fremont who was a delegate to the 2012 Democratic National Convention in Charlotte.)
 

John Freidenrich - CD 18
Atherton, CA

(Rep. Anna Eshoo appointed Mr. Freidenrich, an investor with Regis Management Co.  Mr. Freidenrich is a major financial contributor to Democratic political campaigns.)
 

Jang Badhesha - CD 19
San Jose, CA

(Rep. Zoe Lofgren appointed Jang Badhesha, who apparently is a lab manager at Juniper Networks and a golfer.)

Dennis Donohue - CD 20
Salinas, CA

(Rep. Sam Farr appointed the outgoing Salinas mayor)
 

Dean E. Vogel - CD 21
Davis, CA

(Democratic candidate John Hernandez apparently appointed the president of the California Teachers Association, a non-resident of the district)

Maeley Lock Tom - CD 22
Sacramento, CA

(Democratic candidate Otto Lee apparently appointed a public affairs firm operator, ex-CalPERS board member and State Personnel Board president, a non-resident of the district)
 

Louis Paulson - CD 23
Walnut Creek, CA

(There was not a Democratic candidate for Congress in this congressional district centered on Kern County.  The California Democratic Party apparently appointed Mr. Paulson, a Contra Costa County Fire District employee and political campaign donor, mostly to an International Association of Firefighters political action committee.  He apparently does not reside in this district.)
 

Mollie Culver - CD 24
Santa Barbara, CA

(Rep. Lois Capps appointed Ms. Culver, her campaign manager and a former political director of the California Democratic Party, according to the Ventura County Star website on Dec. 16, 2012.)
 

Christopher Tumbeiro - CD 25
Simi Valley, CA

(Democratic candidate for Congress Lee C. Rogers appointed Mr. Tumbeiro, who is an 18 year-old Royal High School senior, according to the Ventura County Star website on Dec. 16, 2012.)

Sandy Emberland - CD 26
Thousand Oaks, CA

(Ms. Emberland is a volunteer for Democratic congressional candidate Julia Brownley's campaign, according to the Camarillo Acorn of Oct. 19, 2012.  The Ventura County Star reported on Dec. 16, 2012 that Ms. Emberland is a "69-year-old grandmother and retired computer teacher.")

Xiaoguang Sun - CD 27
Cupertino, CA

(Rep. Judy Chu appointed Dr. Sun, who apparently is president of the U.S.-China Agricultural Development Center and president of Ecrossland, Inc. of Cupertino.  He is a non-resident of the district.)

William H. Kysella, Jr. - CD 28
Hollywood, CA

(Rep. Adam Schiff appointed Mr. Kysella, a deputy attorney in the Los Angeles city attorney's office and a member of the state Board of Optometry.)
 

Felipe Fuentes - CD 29
Sylmar, CA

(Congressional candidate Tony Cardenas appointed Mr. Fuentes, who is now a former assemblyman and running for Los Angeles city council in 2013.)
 

John Harold Simpson - CD 30
Encino, CA
 

Alisha Aguilar - CD 31
Redlands, CA
 

Andre Quintero - CD 32
El Monte, CA

(Rep. Grace Napolitano appointed the mayor of El Monte.)
 

Sanford Weiner - CD 33
Los Angeles, CA
 

Maria Teresa Becerra - CD 34
Sacramento, CA

(Rep. Xavier Becerra appointed his mother)
 

Alfonso Sanchez - CD 35
Sacramento, CA

(As the top vote getter among Democratic candidates in the June election, Rep. Joe Baca had the authority to appoint an elector.   Mr. Sanchez, campaign manager of his Democratic rival state Sen. Gloria Negrete McLeod, was somehow appointed. Mr. Sanchez also served as her press secretary in the state senate.  He is a non-resident of the district.)
 

Gregory Lucas Rodriguez - CD 36
Palm Springs, CA

(Democratic congressional candidate Raul Ruiz appointed Gregory Lucas Rodriguez, a self-described "long time Democratic Party and LGBT activist and consultant.")

Diane Watson - CD 37
Los Angeles, CA

(Rep. Karen Bass appointed a former member of Congress)

Laura Lee - CD 38
Cerritos, CA

(Rep. Linda Sanchez appointed a Cerritos city councilmember.)

Karen Chang - CD 39
Hacienda Heights, CA

(Congressional candidate Jay Chen appointed his wife.)

Ricardo Roybal Olivarez - CD 40
Glendale, CA

(Rep. Lucille Roybal-Allard appointed her son, a non-resident of the district. Ricardo Olivarez is an attorney with the firm of the Olivarez Madruga law firm.  The law firm website says that he is "Managing Shareholder of the Firm and the current City Attorney for the City of El Monte and the City of Cudahy.")  He has written about the Ralph M. Brown Act, California's primary local government open meeting law, among other matters.
 

Laurie Stalnaker - CD 41
Highland, CA

(Democratic congressional candidate Mark Takano appointed Ms. Stalnaker, the longtime Executive Secretary/Treasurer at Central Labor Council AFL-CIO of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties.)

Mark Macarro - CD 42
Temecula, CA

(Democratic congressional candidate Michael Williamson apparently appointed Mr. Macarro, tribal chairman of the Pechanga Band of Luiseño Indians.)

Karen Waters - CD 43
Inglewood, CA

(Rep. Maxine Waters appointed her daughter, a political consultant whose firm has done significant business with the congresswoman's campaign committee.)
 

Alexandra Rooker - CD 44
West Sacramento, CA

(Rep. Janice Hahn appointed Ms. Rooker, who apparently is a non-resident of her district.  Ms. Rooker apparently is Alex Gallardo-Rooker, first vice chair of the California Democratic Party and vice president of Communication Workers of America Local 9400.)

Dave Low - CD 45
Sacramento, CA

(Congressional candidiate Sukhee Kang apparently appointed a non-resident.  Dave Low apparently is Executive Director and Director of Governmental Relations of the California School Employees Association.)
 

Michael Ray - CD 46
Laguna Beach, CA

(Rep. Loretta Sanchez apparently appointed Mr. Ray, a non-resident of the district.  He writes a column called "Musings on the Coast" for the Laguna Beach Independent newspaper.  His column describes him, "He makes a living as a real estate entrepreneur and is involved in many non-profits.")

Raymond Cordova - CD 47
Garden Grove, CA

(Congressional candidate Alan Lowenthal appointed Mr. Cordova, who is active in California Democratic Party affairs.)
 

Steven Ray Young - CD 48
Newport Beach, CA

[Congressional candidate Ron Varasteh appointed Mr. Young, who is an attorney.  He is active in state Democratic party affairs and has been Democratic candidate for Congress (2006, 2008) and state senate (2012).]
 

Bobby Glaser - CD 49
San Diego, CA

(Congressional candidate Jerry Tetalman appointed Mr. Glaser, who apparently is owner and president of the La Jolla Group, a firm that specializes in signature gathering for local initiatives.)
 

Bonnie Burns Price - CD 50
La Mesa, CA

(Congressional candidate David Secor appointed Bonnie Burns Price, who has written editorials and other items favoring Democratic political candidates.)
 

Ernesto Encinas - CD 51
San Diego, CA

(Congressional candidate Juan Vargas appointed Mr. Encinas, who apparently is a retired San Diego police detective.  As a retiree, he was a witness in an underage alcohol sale violation case, in which he instructed the "decoy" in the sting operation.)
 

Donald Mullen - CD 52
San Diego, CA

(Congressional candidate Scott Peters appointed Mr. Mullen, chief of staff to San Diego Councilmember Marti Emerald.)
 

Gary Rotto - CD 53
San Diego, CA

(Rep. Susan Davis appointed Mr. Rotto, Director of Health Policy for the Council of Community Clinics, a consortia of 16 private, non-profit health care organizations that provide primary care services primarily to the uninsured and underinsured in San Diego, Imperial and Riverside counties. Mr. Rotto is a frequent contributor to San Diego Jewish World.)

Sunday, June 3, 2012

California's Most Politically Independent Cities-By Party Registration

California Secretary of State Debra Bowen has released city-level voter registration statistics as of May 21, 2012.  The percentage of voters registered with "No Party Preference" has increased in recent decades.

Just under 17.2 million voters are now registered in California: 43.4% are Democrats, 30.2% are Republicans and 21.3% have "No Party Preference," commonly known as "independent" or "decline-to-state" registered voters.

The following are the top fifteen cities with the highest percentages of "No Party Preference" registered voters:

(1)   Cupertino (Santa Clara County), 39.7%
(2)   Milpitas (Santa Clara County), 34.5%
(3)   Walnut (Los Angeles County), 32.7%
(4)   Arcadia (Los Angeles County), 32.1%
(5)   Arcata (Humboldt County), 31.9%
(6)   Monterey Park (Los Angeles County), 31.2%
(7)   San Marino (Los Angeles County), 31.1%
(8)   Rosemead (Los Angeles County), 31.1%
(9)   Sunnyvale (Santa Clara County), 30.8%
(10)  San Francisco, 30.6%
(11)  Saratoga (Santa Clara County), 30.5%
(12)  Temple City (Los Angeles County), 30.4%
(13)  Irvine (Orange County), 30.2%
(14)  Foster City (San Mateo County), 29.8%
(15)  San Gabriel (Los Angeles County), 29.8%

Seven of these cities are located in the San Gabriel Valley of Los Angeles County.  Four are located in Santa Clara County.  Two are college towns (Arcata and Irvine).

A common demographic feature among most of these "politically independent" cities is their high percentage of residents of Asian ancestry, as reported in the 2010 Census of Population: Cupertino (63.3% Asian), Milpitas (62.2% Asian), Walnut (63.6% Asian), Arcadia (59.2% Asian), Monterey Park (66.9% Asian, mostly Chinese), San Francisco (33.3% Asian), Saratoga (41.4% Asian), Temple City (55.7% Asian), Irvine (39.2% Asian), Foster City (45.0% Asian) and San Gabriel (60.7% Asian).  Arcata is an outlier, with just 2.6% of its population with Asian ancestry.

Cupertino, the most politically independent California city in terms of voter registration, is perhaps best known as the headquarters of Apple, Inc.  It is the only California city where "No Party Preference" registered voters (39.7%) outnumber both Democrats (36.7%) and Republicans (21.1%).  The 2010 Census of Population found that 63.3% of Cupertino's 58,000 residents are of Asian ancestry (mostly Chinese and Indian).

The most Democratic cities in California are Coachella in Riverside County (73.8%) and Inglewood (73.7%) and Compton (72.4%) in Los Angeles County, followed by three Salinas Valley/U.S. 101 cities in Monterey County, Greenfield (71.0%), Soledad (69.2%) and Gonzales (68.2%).  The least Democratic cities are Villa Park in Orange County (17.8%), Indian Wells in Riverside County (18.3%) and Rolling Hills on the Palos Verdes Peninsula in Los Angeles County (19.5%).

The most Republican cities in California are Indian Wells (64.3%), Villa Park (63.9%), Canyon Lake in Riverside County (58.3%), Rolling Hills (58.0%), and Kingsburg in Fresno County (56.7%).  Yorba Linda, President Richard Nixon's birthplace, is the sixth most Republican city (56.5%).  Ripon in San Joaquin County, sharing the same name as the city where the Republican Party was founded in the 1850s in Wisconsin, is no. 7 (56.0%).  The least Republican cities are Berkeley (4.8%), Inglewood in Los Angeles County (6.7%) and Oakland (6.9%) and Albany (7.1%) in Alameda County.

The cities with the highest American Independent Party registrations tend to be rural communities: Tehama in Tehama County (9.0%, Montague in Siskiyou County (6.7%), Vernon in Los Angeles County (6.7%), Portola in Plumas County (6.7%), Loyalton in Sierra County (6.3%) and Maricopa in Kern County (6.2%).   Some American Independent Party registrants select this party preference in error, assuming that "American Independent" means "No Party Preference."
 
The cities with the highest Green Party registrations are all in the North Coast counties: Arcata (7.4%) and Blue Lake (6.0%) in Humboldt County, Point Arena in Mendocino County (5.1%), Fairfax in Marin County (4.7%), Trinidad in Humboldt County (4.7%) and Sebastopol in Sonoma County (4.5%).

Monday, January 30, 2012

California State Route 99: Road to the Presidency

The January 31st Florida Republican presidential primary has bought much attention to the Sunshine State's Interstate Highway 4 corridor.  Many reports conclude that winning the I-4 corridor communities, extending from Daytona Beach to Orlando to Tampa, is the key to winning Florida and the presidency. (See, for example, the January 27, 2012 report on PBS-TV's Need to Know and the January 30, 2012 report on NBC News Rock Center.)  California has its own "road to the presidency," State Route 99 in the San Joaquin Valley.

California has not been regarded as a "swing" or "battleground" state since 1992.  However. many communities within the Golden State are presidential bellwethers or microcosms of the national electorate.  As these California cities vote, so goes the presidency.

CalPolitiCal has analyzed city-level presidential voting statistics for all California communities for the five presidential elections beginning in 1992.  Democratic candidates won California in all five elections, but the bellwether cities have generally voted like the nation as a whole, backing George W. Bush in 2004, for example.  CalPolitiCal calculated the absolute value of the difference between each community's presidential vote percentage for the Democratic and Republican candidates and the national vote percentage for each election.  These numbers were summed for five elections to create a "score."  The lower the score, the closer the city voted to the national result.

The following are the twenty California communities that have most closely followed the national popular vote since 1992:

(1) Live Oak (Sutter Co.), 13.9%
(2) Brentwood (Contra Costa Co.), 16.7%
(3) Highland (San Bernardino Co., 17.1%
(4) Riverside (Riverside Co.), 17.8%
(5) Fresno (Fresno Co.), 18.6% (on State Route 99)
(6) Vacaville (Solano Co.), 18.9%
(7) Kerman (Fresno Co.), 20.6%
(8) Grover Beach (San Luis Obispo Co.), 21.1%
(9) Woodland (Yolo Co.), 21.9%
(10) Rio Vista (Solano Co.), 22.4%
(11) Madera (Madera Co.), 23.4% (on State Route 99)
(12) Modesto (Stanislaus Co.), 23.8% (on State Route 99)
(13) Vernon (Los Angeles Co.), 23.8%
(14) Merced (Merced Co.), 24.0% (on State Route 99)
(15) Torrance (Los Angeles Co.), 24.3%
(16) Fowler (Fresno Co.), 24.4% (on State Route 99)
(17) Lakewood (Los Angeles Co.), 24.6%
(18) Sonora (Tuolumne Co.), 24.8%
(19) Stanton (Orange Co.), 25.1%
(20) Dinuba (Tulare Co.), 25.2%

Five of the top 16 California presidential bellwether cities are State Route 99 communities in the San Joaquin Valley: Fresno, Madera, Modesto, Merced and Fowler.  Most of these communities were established around Central Pacific Railroad (later Southern Pacific Railroad) stations in the 1870s.

The City of Live Oak (on the Sacramento Valley segment of Route 99) voted Obama 52.5%-McCain 45.8% in 2008, very close to the national results of Obama 53.1%-McCain 45.8%.  Live Oak voted 0.6% below the nation for Obama and exactly the same as the nation for McCain.  Consequently, Live Oak's "score" for the 2008 presidential election was 0.6%. In 2004, Live Oak voted Bush 51.0%-Kerry 47.7%.  Its results closely corresponded with the national outcome: Bush 51.0%-Kerry 48.5%.

San Joaquin County is the best presidential bellwether county in California, although none of its seven incorporated cities is in the top twenty.  Its "score" for the 1992-2008 presidential elections is 19.3%, comparable to presidential bellwether states such as Florida (18.8%) and Nevada (24.8%).  In other words, if San Joaquin County were a state, presidential candidates likely would flock to it.

Presidential Campaigning in the San Joaquin Valley
Numerous presidents and presidential candidates have visited the Route 99 communities in San Joaquin Valley.  The only Democratic presidential nominees who have won the eight Valley counties since World War II were Harry Truman in 1948, Adlai Stevenson in 1956, John F. Kennedy in 1960 and Lyndon B. Johnson in 1964.  Hubert Humphrey in 1968 and Jimmy Carter in 1976 came close to winning the Valley -- both lost the Valley to Republicans by under 6,000 votes.  The Route 99 corridor is bellwether or "swing" territory, but the rest of the Valley is reliably Republican, generally speaking.

The Valley vote helped to re-elect President Harry Truman in his surprise 1948 victory after his tour through Route 99 communities. Truman won California based on his 32,000 vote margin in the San Joaquin Valley -- he won California as a whole by 18,000 votes.  Truman took special pride in helping to defeat longtime Republican Congressman Bertrand Gearhart, a staunch conservative who had represented Fresno County since 1935.  (Cecil White, the Democrat who defeated Gearhart, lasted just one term in Congress.)

Republican Dwight D. Eisenhower won the San Joaquin Valley in 1952 to Democrat Adlai Stevenson by 30,000 votes, but lost the re-match in the Valley in 1956 by 10,000 votes.

In 1960, John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon campaigned vigorously down the Route 99 corridor.  Sen. Kennedy conducted a "whistle stop" train tour of the San Joaquin Valley on September 9, 1960.  The train stopped in Stockton, Modesto, Turlock, Merced, Madera, Fresno and Tulare, among other Valley communities.

Kennedy said from the rear platform in Stockton: "I think here in this valley you know what can be done. Today is the 110th anniversary of California's admission to the Union. This country and this valley was a desert 100 years ago. It shows what this State can do. It shows what this country can do." In Modesto, Kennedy responded to a question concerning religion from the audience assembled along the train tracks: "There is a question of do I believe all Protestants are heretics. No, and I hope you don't believe all Catholics are. May I say that it seems to me that the great struggle today is between those who believe in no God and those who believe in God. I really don't see why we should engage in close debate over what you may believe and what I may believe. That is my privilege and your privilege."These remarks carried special significance because three days later Kennedy delivered a major speech on religion before Protestant ministers in Houston.  Kennedy said in Turlock, "This valley shows what can be done by community effort. Here in this valley you have harnessed the land and the water for the use of the people."  In Merced, Kennedy noted that it was the 110th anniversary of California statehood, touched on the Lincoln presidential campaign a century earlier and called for the creation of the federal Medicare program.  He also said, "We are campaigning in this State of California because I think this is the place where this election can be won in November."  

The stop in Madera was brief because of rain, Kennedy told the people assembled there.  Fresno was the site of a significant Kennedy speech called "Pathways to Peace."  His advance text said in part, "We are not satisfied with a so-called peace that is merely an interval between two wars. And we are unwilling to accept a peace of slavery, imposed upon us by foreign rulers. Neither do we want the peace of the prison or the grave."  Kennedy also said in Fresno: "This valley and this State have many problems. We traveled today from Sacramento, down through the rain. If that rain continues, there is a chance that the farmers of this valley who grow raisins could lose in 1 day $50 million. It indicates as nothing else does why I think it is important that this country concern itself with what I conceive to be the No.1 domestic problem that the United States faces, and that is the decline in agricultural income."  Kennedy introduced his sister Pat Lawford, then a California resident, at most stops. 

In the final days of the 1960 campaign, on November 4th, then-Vice President Nixon addressed a rally  in downtown Fresno, where he said, "[C]oming to Fresno and seeing all these signs reminds me of the trips that Pat and I have made in previous years out through Sanger and Reedley and all the other towns that we couldn't get to this time - and we thank you for coming not only from there, but we understand from clear down Bakersfield way, from Modesto, Merced, and all the way around. This is really a central California meeting - and, believe me, it means we're on the way in the great Central Valley, and if we're on the way there it means California all the way on November 8 for our ticket."  He also delivered a major television address via KFRE-TV in Fresno (then a CBS affiliate on channel 12).  Also in Fresno on November 4, 1960, Nixon  issued statements on oil and Social Security proposed policies.

In 1960, Kennedy ended up winning the eight San Joaquin Valley counties collectively by 11,000 votes, but losing California by 36,000 ballots.  (Kennedy decisively won Merced, Madera, Fresno and Kings counties, won narrowly in Stanislaus County and lost San Joaquin, Tulare and Kern counties.)

President Lyndon Johnson was the last Democratic presidential nominee who won the San Joaquin Valley.  In 1964, he defeated Republican Sen. Barry Goldwater there by 140,000 votes.  In 1968, Nixon won the Valley by 5,600 ballots, narrowly defeating Democratic Vice President Hubert Humphrey.  Nixon took the Valley decisively in 1972, defeating Democratic Sen. George McGovern by 81,000 votes.

President Jimmy Carter visited Merced (where he held a town hall meeting) and Modesto on the July 4, 1980 Independence Day holiday.  Joy Karin Boese, a girl who asked a question at the Merced event, was invited with her family to a private dinner at the White House with the Carter family and the family of U.S. Rep. Tony Coehlo on August 28, 1980.  (Carter returned to Merced on May 3, 2010 to receive the Alice and Clifford Spendlove Prize in Social Justice, Diplomacy and Tolerance at U.C. Merced.)

Carter lost the San Joaquin Valley to President Gerald Ford in 1976 by a mere 5,000 votes.  Carter came closer to winning the Valley than has any Democratic presidential candidate since the 1964 Johnson landslide.

Read more here: http://www.mercedsunstar.com/2010/05/04/1409543/uc-merced-honors-carter-39th-president.html#storylink=cpy

In 1980, Republican Ronald Reagan swept the Valley as he did most of the nation, winning the Valley by 104,000 votes.  Reagan defeated former Vice President Walter Mondale by 152,000 votes in the Valley in 1984.  Vice President George H.W. Bush won the Valley by 82,000 ballots in 1988.

Democratic Gov. Bill Clinton lost the Valley to President George H.W. Bush in 1992 by 17,000 votes.  Independent presidential candidate Ross Perot won 19.6% of the Valley's 1992 vote. President Clinton had a question-and-answer session with students at Abraham Lincoln Middle School in Selma in September 1995.  A year later, Clinton returned to the Route 99 corridor to speak at another school, Morris E. Dailey Elementary School in Fresno.

Clinton lost the Valley by a wider margin in 1996 to Republican Robert Dole, by 49,000 votes.  Fresno County went narrowly to Clinton in 1992, but flipped to Dole in 1996.  The Republican margin of victory increased in Kern County from 20,000 votes in 1992 to 30,000 votes in 1996.

In 2000, Gov. George W. Bush defeated Vice President Al Gore in the Valley by 118,000 votes.

First Lady Michelle Obama addressed the graduates of U.C. Merced in May 2009.  A few months earlier, Barack Obama lost the Valley by 32,000 votes, but won San Joaquin, Stanislaus, Merced and Fresno counties.  Four years earlier, Democrat John Kerry lost the Valley to President George W. Bush by 214,000 votes.

Thursday, September 1, 2011

San Francisco Bay Area Television-25 Years of Early Morning News

Today the early morning television airwaves in the San Francisco Bay Area are saturated with local news broadcasts.  Five stations (KTVU, KRON, KPIX, KGO and KNTV) produce a total of 17 hours of local news on weekdays between 4 a.m. and 9 a.m.  Twenty-five years ago, in the summer of 1986, the same stations produced zero hours of local news (excepting the local cut-ins to network programs at 7:25 and 8:25 a.m.).

The world of Bay Area television news broadcasting changed on Monday, September 1 (Labor Day), 1986 when KRON-TV (channel 4, then an NBC affiliate) debuted "Daybreak," a half-hour local newscast from 6:30 a.m. to 7 a.m.  "NewsCenter 4 Daybreak" was then the only local newscast on the Bay Area television dial between 4 a.m. and 9 a.m. (aside from the five-minute cut-ins to the network morning programs at 7:25 and 8:25 a.m.).  Lloyd Patterson and Lila Petersen were the co-anchors.  This half-hour program a quarter century ago spawned the seven hours on KRON (4 a.m. to 11 a.m.), 4 1/2 hours on KTVU (4:30 a.m. to 9 a.m.) and 2 1/2 hours on KPIX, KGO and KNTV (4:30 a.m. to 7 a.m.) that Bay Area viewers see today.

"Daybreak" had a texture that was different from KRON's other newscasts in 1986.  Traffic reporting was heavily emphasized.  Newscasts generally began with live shots of traffic conditions at the toll plazas of the Bay Bridge and Golden Gate Bridge (live traffic cameras were a rarity then).  Much of the content was from KRON's newscasts that aired the previous day.  [For example, the evening anchors' (Jim Paymar and Sylvia Chase) laughter sometimes could be heard during the taped Wayne Shannon commentaries that aired during "Daybreak."]  The New York Stock Exchange began trading at 6:30 a.m. PT, giving 'Daybreak' an opportunity to be among the few broadcast television sources of opening-bell market trends (aside from the Financial News Network on San Jose's channel 48, which had yet to convert to its Spanish language Telemundo format.)  "Bumpers" before commercial breaks included trivia questions and cartoon clips.  A mid-1987 promo summarized what made 'Daybreak' distinctive: "“When the day begins, ‘Daybreak’ is ready.  With local news, stocks, weather and live traffic reports.  Daybreak – the Bay Area’s first newscast.  Weekdays at 6:30.”When the day begins, ‘Daybreak’ is ready.  With local news, stocks, weather and live traffic reports.  'Daybreak' – the Bay Area’s first newscast.  Weekdays at 6:30."
“When the day begins, ‘Daybreak’ is ready.  With local news, stocks, weather and live traffic reports.  Daybreak – the Bay Area’s first newscast.  Weekdays at 6:30.”“When the day begins, ‘Daybreak’ is ready.  With local news, stocks, weather and live traffic reports.  Daybreak – the Bay Area’s first newscast.  Weekdays at 6:30.”

KNTV (channel 11), then the ABC affiliate in the San Jose/Salinas/Monterey television market, in 1987 or early 1988 followed KRON with its 15-minute "Good Morning San Jose" program at 6:45 a.m., displacing the last quarter of the hour-long "ABC World News This Morning."

In January 1988, KGO-TV (channel 7, ABC owned & operated station) announced that it would challenge KRON with its own early morning newscasts, two 15-minute newscasts at 6:00 a.m. and 6:30 a.m., interspersed with 15-minute segments of "ABC World News This Morning" at 6:15 and 6:45 a.m.  It was on the air by mid-1988.  Russ Coughlan, former KGO general manager, was the anchor of a low-budget newscast that featured Coughlan holding up and reading morning newspapers on the air.  KGO touted the fact that its newscast began earlier than KRON's, beginning a "war" for earlier and earlier start times.

The earth literally shook before KPIX-TV (channel 5, then a Westinghouse-owned CBS affiliate) entered the early morning news race.  Its 6:30 a.m. newscast evolved out of special coverage following the October 17, 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake.  By that time KRON had already expanded "Daybreak" to a full hour, beginning at 6 a.m.

KTVU (channel 2, Cox Broadcasting-owned Fox affiliate) began competing in the early morning news market in January 1991 when "Mornings on 2" debuted from 7 a.m. to 9 a.m., featuring host Steve McPartlin, news anchor Terry Lowry and reporter Eric Greene.  Its competitive advantage was that it was the only local newscast against the network programs during its two-hour time slot.  It was then said to be the first local newscast in the western United States to challenge the network programs.  "Mornings on 2" replaced a two-hour children's block, including "G.I. Joe," "Adventures of the Gummi Bears," "Duck Tales" and "Merrie Melodies."

In August 1996, KTVU added a 6 a.m. to 7 a.m. newscast called the "KTVU Morning News," anchored by Dianne Dwyer and Ross McGowan.  That newscast expanded earlier to 5:30 a.m. in August 1998.  Today it begins at 4:30 a.m.

In the early 1990s, local stations increased their local cut-ins to network programs.  In 1992, for example, KRON added 7:55 and 8:55 a.m. five-minute newscasts to join its 7:25 and 8:25 a.m. ones.  "Daybreak" had expanded to two hours (5 a.m. to 7 a.m.) by 1998.  Now KRON begins its local newscasts at 4 a.m., a half-hour earlier than its four rivals.

KPIX ran a local newscast called "Channel 5 This Morning" during the 7 a.m. to 8 a.m. hour in mid-1996.  Anchored by Marcia Brandwynne, it was blended with network content.  KPIX ran a network news program from 8 a.m. to 9 a.m.

Cox Broadcasting, KTVU's owner, bought KICU-TV in San Jose in 1999.  In 2000, KTVU simulcast "Mornings on 2" on KICU. KICU occasionally broke away from KTVU to air Santa Clara County-focused items.

KRON "Daybreak" anchors in the 1990s included Susan Blake (began in 1990) and John Kessler.  [Here are "Daybreak" promos from 1997 and 1999 (featuring John Kessler, Darya Folsom, Christine Nubla, Michelle Franzen and Brian Hackney).]  In January 2002, KRON lost its NBC affiliation and became "independent."  It created its "KRON 4 Morning News" in the 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. timeslot to replace the "Today" program that moved to KNTV.  Eventually the "Daybreak" name was removed from the pre-7 a.m. broadcast.

KCRA-TV, the NBC affiliate in Sacramento, has produced an early morning newscast longer than any Bay Area station.  Well before "Daybreak" premiered on KRON in 1986, KCRA had long broadcast an hour-long "Channel 3 Reports" program from 6 to 7 a.m.

KMST-TV (now KCCN-TV), the CBS affiliate in Monterey (channel 46), also may have beaten KRON to the early morning airwaves.  In September 1986, it aired a 15-minute program called "Morning in Monterey" at 6:15 a.m.

KSBW-TV, the NBC affiliate in Salinas (channel 8), was perhaps one of the last NBC stations that had no local morning newscast whatsoever.  It began producing 7:25 and 8:25 a.m. newscasts in early 1987.  Its first early morning newscast began in August 1987 in the 6:30 to 7 a.m. time slot, featuring Diane Guerrazzi as anchor and Jim Adamson as weatherman.  (KSBW's 11:30 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. newscasts began the same day, effectively doubling the station's weekday local news productions.)

To make room for "Daybreak," KRON moved the half-hour "NBC News at Sunrise," then anchored by Bob Jamieson, to the 6 to 6:30 a.m. time slot.  "Sunrise" displaced an morning re-broadcast of the previous evening's "Entertainment Tonight."  In August 1986, KRON's five-minute news breaks at 6:45, 7:25 and 8:25 a.m. were called "Daybreak" so that program title antedated the half-hour newscast that began in September 1986.

The "Daybreak" logo was a rising sun that was reminiscent of the logo for NBC's "Today" program.  "Today" co-anchors Bryant Gumbel and Jane Pauley cut promos in 1986 for KRON's "Daybreak."  Pauley's five second promo implored viewers to "Give your 'Today' a great start.  Watch NewsCenter 4 'Daybreak.'"

Today five Bay Area stations air local newscasts at 6:30 a.m. weekdays.  When "Daybreak" premiered on KRON in that time slot in 1986, its competition was "Alvin and the Chipmunks" cartoon on KTVU, the "CBS Early Morning News" on KPIX, the last half-hour of "ABC World News This Morning" on KGO.

Saturday, July 23, 2011

California State Senate District Numbering: Special Election Law Should Be Amended


The issue of odd/even state senate district numbering has vexed the California political system after every decennial redistricting since the scheme began 132 years ago. Due to shifting district numbers and lines, citizens inevitably are subject to “deferrals” (having no senator until a year ending with “4”) and “accelerations” (having two senators during that period).

If a senate seat that will be elected in November 2014 becomes vacant early, current state law strangely requires use of “old” district borders in special elections held before then, even though “new” districts take effect for other senators in 2012. Absurdly, un-represented residents of the new district are deprived of an opportunity to resolve their “deferral” while residents of the old district may get to elect two senators a few months apart (or even on the same day).  

Courts have upheld this practice, but have not forbidden alternatives.  In Legislature v. Reinecke (1973), the California Supreme Court held there was no violation of the 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause in the continuance of staggered terms in state senate elections following redistricting.
The court observed that if the California Constitution's provision concerning staggered terms were given effect, the senators in odd districts elected in 1972 were entitled to serve until 1976, and if vacancies occurred in those districts before 1976, they would be filled using the 1972 districts.  This is a longstanding principle, earlier upheld in People ex rel. Snowball v. Pendegast (1892).  However, no court apparently has required this practice.

California Elections Code sec. 10704 mandates that special elections be held in "the district in which the vacancy occurred." The Legislature ought to revise sec. 10704 to mandate that new senate district boundaries be used in all special elections on and after November Election Day in years ending “2.” Otherwise, Governor Brown should order use of new districts in special election proclamations that he issues pursuant to California Constitution, Article IV, sec. 2 (“When a vacancy occurs in the Legislature the Governor immediately shall call an election to fill the vacancy.”). These remedies would ensure that senators represent as many Californians as possible.

UPDATE (December 8, 2012): State Sen. Doug LaMalfa resigned his senate seat in September 2012 in anticipation of his victory in the vacant 1st Congressional District race in November 2012.  Consequently, a special election to determine his replacement in the "old" 4th Senate District was held on November Election Day.

The "old" 4th Senate District included all of Del Norte, Siskiyou, Shasta, Butte, Tehama, Glenn, Colusa, Sutter and Yuba counties and portions of Nevada and Placer (Rocklin, Lincoln, Loomis) counties.  The "new" 4th Senate District encompasses a much smaller geographic area: all of Tehama, Glenn, Colusa, Sutter, Yuba and Butte counties plus portions of Placer (city of Roseville) and Sacramento counties.

Siskiyou and Shasta counties, western Nevada County (Grass Valley/Nevada City) and the Lincoln/Loomis/Rocklin area of Placer County, have been transferred to the new 1st Senate District.  Consequently, voters in those areas voted for two state senators on the November 2012 ballot (the "old" 4th District and the new 1st District).  Del Norte and Trinity counties were transferred from the old 4th District to the new 2nd Senate District (but they voted in November 2012 for the special senate election in the "old" 4th District).

The city of Roseville in Placer County presently does not have representation in the state senate as it was part of the "old" 1st Senate District (which no longer exists) and is part of the "new" 4th Senate District (next election is in November 2014).  Therefore, Roseville is a "deferral" state senate jurisdiction.

Had Elections Code sec. 10704 been amended or had Governor Brown issued a special election proclamation declaring that the "new" Senate District 4 been "the district in which the vacancy occurred," then the city of Roseville would be represented in the state senate the next two years and Siskiyou and Shasta counties and the Grass Valley/Nevada City area of Nevada County would have been spared the second senate election.